Tourist industries and the “right to the city”: Constructing local identity in post-Soviet Sortavala through the access to tourism resources

Authors

  • Egor A. Kuznetsov National Research University “Higher School of Economics” Автор
  • Varvara A. Mikhailovskaya National Research University “Higher School of Economics” Автор

Keywords:

Sortavala, tourism economy, informal Economy, tourism crafts, tourism resources, right to the city, local identity

Abstract

The article considers grassroots economic practices in the tourism sector of Sortavala, a town in northwestern Russia, which has undergone significant transformation following the COVID-19 pandemic and the closure of international borders in the 2020s. In the absence of large industrial enterprizes, domestic tourism has become a primary economic activity for local residents. The authors focus on tourism crafts - f lexible, small-scale, and often informal practices that aim at self-sufficiency - to show how they adapt to the region’s unstable social-economic conditions. These practices differ from both precarious wage labor and formal entrepreneurship, representing a distinct mode of engagement with the tourist economy, which is widely perceived as the only viable and strategically promising development path. Based on the qualitative study conducted in 2023-2024, the authors argue that access to tourism resources (places, infrastructure, narratives, and natural environments), which can be monetized through tourist interactions, serves as the central factor of participation in this economy. This access is unevenly distributed, has become a key site of social conflicts, and serves as not only an economic opportunity but also a mechanism for expressing and enacting a sense of belonging. Through tourism crafts, local actors assert a form of the “right to the city” - the right not only to inhabit but also to actively shape urban and natural spaces. Thus, grassroots involvement in tourism functions as a medium for articulating and renegotiating local identity.

References

Александрова А. Ю. (2012). Политико-административные границы: от барьера к туристскому ресурсу // Вестник Московского университета. Серия 5. География. № 3. С. 15-20.

Бойм С. (2019). Будущее ностальгии. М.: Новое литературное обозрение.

Брубейкер Р. (2012). Этничность без групп / Пер. с англ. И. Борисовой. М.: Издательский дом Высшей школы экономики.

Веселкова Н. В., Прямикова Е. В. (2024). Состояние постиндустриальности: "власть заводов" // Интеракция. Интервью. Интерпретация. Т. 16. № 3. С. 10-32.

Кордонский С. Г. (2010). Россия. Поместная федерация. М.: Издательство "Европа".

Королев К. М. (2024). "Право на город": Кронштадт глазами горожан // Фольклор и антропология города. Т. 6. № 1-2. С. 39-57.

Лефевр А. (2015). Производство пространства / Пер. с фр. И. Стаф. М.: Strelka Press.

Макканелл Д. (2023). Турист. Новая теория праздного класса / Пер. с англ. А. Боровикова, Е. Изотов. М.: Ad Marginem.

Матвеева Э. Г. (2021). Народная история Сортавалы в рассказах местных жителей // Фольклор и антропология города. Т. 4. № 1-2. С. 42-75.

Матвеева Э. Г., Радченко Д. А., Петров Н. В. (2021). Город в историях людей - Сортавала. М.: Неолит.

Мельникова Е. А. (2015). Локальное прошлое на границе национального: краеведческие музеи Северного Приладожья в постсоветское время // Антропологический форум. № 25. С. 9-41.

Плюснин Ю. М. (2024). Промыслы российской провинции: неформальные экономические практики населения. М.: Издательский дом Высшей школы экономики.

Плюснин Ю. М. (2022). Социальная структура провинциального общества. М.: Common Place.

Савельев Ю. В., Толстогузов О. В. (ред.) (2008). Управление развитием туризма в регионе. Опыт реализации стратегии Республики Карелия. Петрозаводск: Издательство Карельского научного центра РАН.

Селеев С. С., Павлов А. Б. (2016). Гаражники. М.: Страна Оз.

Alamineh G. A., Hussein J. W., Endaweke Y., Taddesse B. (2023). The local communities' perceptions on the social impact of tourism and its implication for sustainable development in Amhara regional state // Heliyon. Vol. 9. № 6.

Cowan T., Campbell B., Kalb D. (2023). Theorizing peripheral labor: Rethinking "surplus populations" // Focaal. Vol. 97. P. 7-21.

Duxbury N., de Castro T. V., Silva S. (2025). Culture-tourism entanglements: Moving from grassroots practices to regenerative cultural policies in smaller communities // International Journal of Cultural Policy. Vol. 31. № 4. P. 497-516.

Harvey D. (2008). The right to the city // New Left Review. № 53. P. 23-40.

Holden A. (2006). Tourism Studies and the Social Sciences. London: Routledge.

Izotov A. (2018). Mapping Sortavala: Local Identity Formation in a Soviet and Post-Soviet Border Town. DIIS Working Paper. Copenhagen: Danish Institute for International Studies.

Izotov A., Laine J. (2013). Constructing (un)Familiarity: role of tourism in identity and region building at the Finnish-Russian border // European Planning Studies. Vol. 21. № 1. P. 93-111.

Kondrateva S. V. (2021). Project approach to transboundary tourism-and-recreation region building: The case of Karelia // Baltic Region. Vol. 13. № 1. P. 124-137.

Laine J. (2017). Finnish-Russian border mobility and tourism: Localism overruled by geopolitics // Tourism and Geopolitics: Issues and Concepts from Central and Eastern Europe / D. Hall (ed.). Wallingford: CABI. P. 178-190.

Lefebvre H. (1996). The right to the city // Writings on Cities / E. Kofman, E. Lebas (trs.). Oxford: Blackwell. P. 63-184.

Łukianow M., Wells C. (2024). Territorial phantom pains: Third-generation postmemories of territorial changes // Memory Studies. Vol. 17. № 2. P. 177-192.

Mayers J. (2005). Stakeholder Power Analysis. London: International Institute for Environment and Development.

Mee K. (2009). A space to care, a space of care: Public housing, belonging, and care in inner Newcastle, Australia // Environment and Planning A. Vol. 41. № 4. P. 842-858.

Mee K., Wright S. (2009). Geographies of Belonging // Environment and Planning A. Vol. 41. № 4. P. 772-779.

Muganda M., Sirima A., Ezra P. M. (2013). The role of local communities in tourism development: Grassroots Perspectives from Tanzania // Journal of Human Ecology. Vol. 41. № 1. P. 53-66.

Purcell M. (2002). Excavating Lefebvre: The right to the city and its urban politics of the inhabitant // GeoJournal. Vol. 58. P. 99-108.

Rogerson C. M., Letsie T. (2013). Informal sector business tourism in the Global South: Evidence from Maseru, Lesotho // Urban Forum. Vol. 24. P. 485-502.

Smith W. (2024). Tourism Cares. How Community-Based Tourism Empowers Locals and Enhances Travel. URL: https://www.tourismcares.org/tourism-cares-blog/how-community-based-tourism-empowers-locals-and-enhances-travel (дата доступа: 10.06.2025).

Stepanova S. (2016). The role of tourism in the development of Russia's Northwestern border regions // Baltic Region. № 3. P. 109-120.

Stepanova S. V. (2019). The Northern Ladoga Region as a prospective tourist destination in the Russian-Finnish borderland: Historical, cultural, ecological and economic aspects // Geographia Polonica. Vol. 92. № 4. P. 409-428.

Tribe J. (1997). The indiscipline of tourism // Annals of Tourism Research. Vol. 24. № 3. P. 638-657.

Published

2025-01-01