A few methodological notes based on the field observations of rural human capital in the Russia's Non-Black Earth Region
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.22394/2500-1809-2024-9-2-6-19Keywords:
(repeated) case study, field research, typology, analytical generalizations, rural entrepreneur, rural human capital, positive and negative trends, local authorities, rural community, formal and informal interactionAbstract
The article presents some methodological considerations on the possibilities and limitations of the qualitative approach (repeated case studies in the specific Russian region) for the sociological assessment of human capital. In the first part of the article, the author considers the Russian tradition of rural studies as combining two analytical ‘optics' - sociological/ethnographic observations of local realities based on various combinations of qualitative techniques and a strong anthropological/ peasant-studies emphasis with large-scale social surveys aimed at macro-descriptions of agrarian reforms, rural social/human capital and agro-industrial complex under the persistent trends of social-spatial differentiation. In the second part, the author mentions the key possibilities and limitations of case studies for assessing the state and prospects of rural human capital in the most depressed rural region of Russia, focusing on the role of entrepreneurs in formal and informal support of the local rural economy and communities in cooperation with municipal and regional authorities. In the final part, the author emphasizes typologies as the analytical result of rural case studies (especially the repeated ones) and provides examples - ‘types' of the local agricultural producer relationships with the rural settlement's authorities and community (as the basis for preserving rural human capital) and ‘types' of the rural entrepreneurs' biographical trajectories (as the basis for the generational continuity of this differentiated rural stratum).References
Allina-Pisano J. (2008) The Post-Soviet Potemkin Village. Politics and Property Rights in the Black Earth, Cambridge University Press.
Averkieva K. V. (2017) Symbiosis of agriculture and forestry in the early-developed periphery of the Non-Black Earth Region: The case of the Tarnogsky district of the Vologda Region.Russian Peasant Studies, vol. 2, no 4. (In Russian)
Banfield E. C. (2019) The Moral Basis of a Backward Society, Moscow. (In Russian)
Bozhkov O. B. (2019) Family entrepreneurship in the countryside: Some details of the portrait. RUDN Journal of Sociology, vol. 19, no 4. (In Russian)
Bozhkov O. B., Ignatova S. N., Trotsuk I. V., Nikulin A. M. (2022) Rural Entrepreneurs in the Northern Non-Black Earth Region: Sociological Essays Based on Field Observations, Moscow. (In Russian)
Bozhkov O. B., Nikulin A. M., Poleshchuk I. K. (2020) Agricultural cooperation in the Northern Non-Black-Earth Region: Formal and informal practices. RUDN Journal of Sociology, vol. 20, no 4. (In Russian)
Bozhkov O. B., Trotsuk I. V. (2018) Tendencies of the Russian rural areas development: The research task and first results of the comparative case-study. RUDN Journal of Sociology, vol. 18, no 4. (In Russian)
Bozhkov O. B., Trotsuk I. V. (2020) Post-Soviet farmers' international in the agriculture of the North-West Region. Russian Peasant Studies, vol. 5, no 4. (In Russian)
Clement K. (2021) Patriotism from Below. "How Is It Possible for People to Live so Poorly in Such a Rich Country?", Moscow. (In Russian)
Denisenko M. B., Denisenko G. M., Efremenko D. V. et al. (2016) Townspeople in the Village: Sociological Research in the Russian Hinterland: Deurbanization and Rural-Urban Communities, Moscow. (In Russian)
Efimov V. M. (2009) Evolutionary analysis of the Russian agrarian institutional system. Universe of Russia. Sociology. Ethnology, no 1. (In Russian)
Ely C. (2022) Russian Populism: A History, Bloomsbury Publishing.
Fadeeva O. P. (2003) Rural entrepreneurs in the local community. Journal of Economic Sociology, vol. 4, no 2. (In Russian)
Fadeeva O. P. (2015) Rural Communities and Economic Structures: From Survival to Development, Novosibirsk. (In Russian)
Fadeeva O. P. (2018) Sketches for the farm project: An Altai palette.Russian Peasant Studies, vol. 3, no 1. (In Russian)
Fadeeva O. P. (2019) Siberian village: From formal self-administration to the forced self-organization. ECO, no 4. (In Russian)
Fadeeva O. P., Nefedkin V. I. (2020) Informal public-private partnership as an initiative from below: Rural cases.Russian Peasant Studies, vol. 5, no 3. (In Russian)
Fedotova V. G. (1997) Modernization of the "Other" Europe, Moscow. (In Russian)
From Family Homesteads to the Far Eastern Hectare (2021): Non-Trivial Issues of Public Administration and Municipal Government, Moscow. (In Russian)
Gordeeva I. A. (2003) "Forgotten People": History of the Russian Communitarian Movement, Moscow. (In Russian)
Gusfield J. R. (1967) Tradition and modernity: Misplaced polarities in the study of social change. American Journal of Sociology, vol. 74, no 4.
Hann C. et al. (Eds.) (2003) The Postsocialist Agrarian Question. Property Relations and the Rural Condition, vol. 1, Münster.
Kalugina Z. I. (2001) Paradoxes of the Agrarian Reform in Russia. Sociological Analysis of Transformation Processes, Novosibirsk. (In Russian)
Kalugina Z. I., Fadeeva O. P. (2009) Russian Village in the Labyrinth of Reforms: Sociological Sketches, Novosibirsk. (In Russian)
Kolesnikov N., Tolstoguzov O. (2016) Structural changes in the economy of the Russian Northwest: A spatial dimension. Baltic Region, no 2. (In Russian)
Krasilshchikov V. V. (1993) Modernization and Russia on the threshold of the 21st century. Issues of Philosophy, no 7. (In Russian)
Kuznetsova T. E. (2009). Multi-Structure of the Russian Economy: Historical Roots, State and Prospects, Moscow. (In Russian)
Lester D. (1998) Feudalism's revenge: The inverse dialectics of time in Russia. Contemporary Politics, vol. 4, no 2.
Lindner P., Moser E. (2011) (De)centralization of rural Russia: Local self-government and the "vertical of power". Peasant Studies: Theory. History. The Present Time, vol. 6, Moscow. (In Russian)
Maksimov A. F. (2018) Quantitative analysis and assessment of the number of agricultural consumer cooperatives. Applied Economic Research, no 6. (In Russian)
Naumova N. F. (1999) Recurrent Modernization in Russia: Misfortune, Guilt or Resource of Humanity? Moscow. (In Russian)
Nefedova T. G. (2003) Rural Russia at the Crossroads: Geographical Essays, Moscow. (In Russian)
Nefedova T. G. (2013) Ten Actual Questions about Rural Russia: Answers of the Geographer, Moscow. (In Russian)
Nefedova T. G. (2021) Polarization of the social-economic space and prospects of rural areas in the old-developed regions of Central Russia. Russian Peasant Studies, vol. 6, no 1. (In Russian)
Nikula J., Kopoteva I. (2020) Local development initiatives in the Lake Ladoga Region: Reasons for success and approaches to funding. RUDN Journal of Sociology, vol. 20, no 1.
Nikulin A., Trotsuk I. (2022a) Political and apolitical dimensions of Russian rural development: Populism "from above" and narodnik small deeds "from below". Politics and Policies of Rural Authenticity. (Ed. by P. Pospěch, E. M. Fuglestad, E. Figueiredo), Routledge.
Nikulin A. M. (2010) Oligarchoz as a successor of postkolkhoz. Economic Sociology, vol. 11, no 1. (In Russian)
Nikulin A. M. (2012) Second Russia: Differentiation and Self-Organization, Moscow. (In Russian)
Nikulin A. M., Trotsuk I. V. (2014) Rural development in Finland: Interaction of the state, farmers and science (possible lessons for Russia). Universe of Russia. Sociology. Ethnology, no 3. (In Russian)
Nikulin A. M., Trotsuk I. V. (2022b) Humanitarian populism.Russian Sociological Review, vol. 21, no 4.
Nureev R. M., Shulgin S. G. (2006) The relationship between economic and political monopolism in Russian regions: Administrative resource and forms of its manifestation. Economic Bulletin of the Rostov State University, vol. 4, no 3. (In Russian)
Olshansky D. V. (2001) Psychology of the Contemporary Russian Politics, Moscow. (In Russian)
Ovchintseva L. A. (2020) Case-study method in the studies of the Russian rural cooperation. RUDN Journal of Sociology, vol. 20, no 3. (In Russian)
Ovchintseva L. A. (2021) New villagers: motives and factors for moving from urban to rural areas. RUDN Journal of Sociology, vol. 21, no 2. (In Russian)
Pain E. A., Volkogonova O. D. (Eds.) (2008).Russian Modernization: Reflections on Its Originality, Moscow. (In Russian)
Patsiorkovsky V. V. (2003) Rural Russia: 1991-2002, Moscow. (In Russian)
Petrick M. (2022) Post-Soviet transformation of agriculture: A success after all? The Russian Peasant Studies, vol. 7, no 1, pp. 103-130. (In Russian)
Pilyasov A. N. (2009) And the Last Will be First: Northern Periphery on the Way to a Knowledge Economy, Moscow. (In Russian)
Popov E. A. (2022) Social functions of rural farmers (on the example of the Altai Region).RUDN Journal of Sociology, vol. 22, no 3. (In Russian)
Saraikin A. V., Yanbykh R. G. (2018) Classification of cooperatives and development of agricultural cooperation. AIC: Economics, Management, no 7. (In Russian)
Savoskul M. S., Alekseev A. I. (2021) Trajectories of transformation of one unpromising village (on the example of the village Kuzreka in the Tersk district of the Murmansk Region).Russian Peasant Studies, vol. 6, no 3. (In Russian)
Scott J. C. (1985) Weapons of the Weak: Everyday Forms of Peasant Resistance, Yale University Press.
Shagaida N. I. (2010) Agricultural Land Turnover in Russia: Transformation of Institutions and Practice, Moscow. (In Russian)
Shagaida N. I., Yanbykh R. G., Uzun V.Ya. et al. (Eds.) (2019) On the State of Rural Areas in the Russian Federation in 2017. Annual Report on the Results of Monitoring, Moscow. (In Russian)
Toshchenko Z. T. (2018) Features of the life world of rural residents in Russia. Sociological Studies, no 2. (In Russian)
Toshchenko Zh.T. (Eds.) (2016) Meanings of Rural Life (Sociological Analysis), Moscow. (In Russian)
Trotsuk I. V. (2007) Possibilities of the case study method in the study of rural social problems. RUDN Journal of Sociology, no 4. (In Russian)
Trotsuk I. V. (2014) "Second Russia": Ways for "identification" and discursive presentation. Paths of Russia. New Languages of Social Description, Moscow. (In Russian)
Trotsuk I. V. (2016) Social aspects of Russian geography: A new round of the studies of the space transformations between two Russian capitals. RUDN Journal of Sociology, vol. 16, no 4. (In Russian)
Trotsuk I. V. (2019a) Rural development monitorings: "quantity", "quality", or a combination of both?. Proceedings of the IX Grushin Conference "Social Engineering: How Sociology Changes the World", Moscow. (In Russian)
Trotsuk I. V. (2019b) Similarities and differences between two sociological discourses about rural Russia. Scientific Notes of the Crimean Federal University named after V. I. Vernadsky. Sociology. Pedagogy. Psychology, no 2. (In Russian)
Trotsuk I. V. (2020) Qualitative and quantitative format of rural sociological monitorings: opportunity or need? Social-Economic and Humanitarian Journal of the Krasnoyarsk State Agrarian University, no 3. (In Russian)
Uzun V.Ya., Shagaida N. I. (2015) Agrarian Reform in Post-Soviet Russia: Mechanisms and Results, Moscow. (In Russian)
Uzun V.Ya., Shagaida N. I., Gataulina E. A., Shishkina E. A. (2022) Holdings in the Russian Agricultural Business, Moscow. (In Russian)
Veliky P. P., Morekhina M.Yu. (2004) Adaptive potential of rural society. Sociological Studies, no 12. (In Russian)
Vinogradskaya O. Y. (2022) Estimates of the land reform of the 1990s thirty years later. RUDN Journal of Sociology, vol. 22, no 1. (In Russian)
Vinogradskaya O.Ya. (2019) Why and from what townspeople move to the village: Phenomenology and practice. Russian Peasant Studies, vol. 4, no 3. (In Russian)
Vinogradsky V. G. (2009) Weapons of the Weak: Technology and Social Logic of Everyday Peasant Life, Saratov. (In Russian)
Vinogradsky V. G., Vinogradskaya O.Ya. (2022) Farming and the rural world: A generational change. Russian Peasant Studies, vol. 7, no 1. (In Russian)
Vorbrugg A. (2018) Not about land, not quite a grab: Dispersed dispossession in rural Russia. Russian Peasant Studies, vol. 3, no 3. (In Russian)
Vorbrugg A. (2020) Ethnographies of slow violence: Studying the effects of rural disintegration. Russian Peasant Studies, vol. 5, no 1. (In Russian)
Wegren S. (2016) Нousehold inequality and village discord: Toward a post-socialist moral economy. Russian Peasant Studies, vol. 1, no 1.
Wegren S., Trotsuk I. V. (2019) The paradoxes of smallholders in contemporary Russia. Russian Peasant Studies, vol. 4, no 4.
Yastrebinskaya G. A. (2005) Taiga Village Kobelevo. History of the Soviet Village in Russian Peasant Narratives: 1992-2002, Moscow. (In Russian)
