Utopias of Alexander Bogdanov and Alexander Chayanov: The choice of rural-urban development and its consequences for rural human capital and social differentiation
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.22394/2500-1809-2023-8-4-23-40Keywords:
Chayanov, Bogdanov, utopia, proletariat, peasantry, marxism, corporatism, colonialism, human capitalAbstract
A science-based conversation about the current state of rural areas, prospects for rural human capital and trends in rural differentiation is impossible without the conceptual approaches and futuristic projects of great Russian agrarian scientists. The article presents an attempt of comparing such ideas of two outstanding social thinkers of the early 20th century - Alexander Bogdanov and Alexander Chayanov, focusing on their utopias as representing the essential features (proletarian and peasant) of their social-economic and cultural-ethical views. Bogdanov and Chayanov had extensive encyclopedic knowledge and brilliant organizational skills; they wrote original works on social philosophy and political economy; both were prominent leaders of alternative social-political directions of the Russian Revolution. Moreover, Bogdanov and Chayanov wrote several famous utopias: Bogdanov’s utopia develops Marxist ideas of proletarian revolution and construction of socialism not only on earth but also in space; Chayanov’s utopia of moderate cooperative socialism defends the new revolutionary significance of the peasantry. The proletarian ideologist Bogdanov was skeptical about the political potential of the peasantry, arguing that opponents of proletarian revolution would use peasant conservatism against socialist revolution. The peasant ideologist Chayanov was skeptical about the creative potential of the working class, predicting that in the coming social revolution it would be used to build authoritarian-bureaucratic socialism. However, both thinkers sought prospects for rural-urban development through the analysis of possible ways of interaction between man and nature. Despite the ignorance of the positive revolutionary potential of the proletariat (Chayanov) and the peasantry (Bogdanov), both thinkers made huge contributions to the theory and practice of the Russian Revolution, and their utopian ideas still inspire the search for a new just, humane and happy world.References
Alexander Bogdanov and the Origins of Systems Thinking in Russia (1998) (Ed. by J. Biggart, P. Dudley, F. King), Aldershot: Ashgate.
Banaji J. (1976) Chayanov, Kautsky, Lenin: Considerations towards a synthesis. Economic and Political Weekly, no 11, pp. 1594-1607.
Bernstein H. (2009) V. I. Lenin and A. V. Chayanov: Looking back, looking forward. Journal of Peasant Studies, vol. 36, no 1, pp. 55-81.
Biggart J. (1989) Alexander Bogdanov, left Bolshevism and the Proletkult 1904-1932, University of East Anglia.
Bogdanov A. (1914) The Science of Social Consciousness, Moscow: Publishing House of Writers. (In Russian)
Bogdanov A. (1918) Fates of the Workers' Party in the current revolution. Part 1. New Life, no 19. (In Russian)
Bogdanov A. (2017) The Philosophy of Living Experience: Popular Outlines, Haymarket Books. (In Russian)
Bogdanov A.A. (1911) Cultural Tasks of Our Time, Moscow: S. Dorovatovsky and A. Charushnikov Publishing House. (In Russian)
Bogdanov A.A. (1987) A Short Course on Economics, Moscow: Publishing House of A. M. Murinova. (In Russian)
Bogdanov A. A. (1908) Red Star, Saint Petersburg. (In Russian)
Bogdanov A. A. (1912) Engineer Manny, Moscow. (In Rusian)
Bogdanov A. A. (1924) On Proletarian Culture. 1904-1924, Moscow-Leningrad: Kniga. (In Russian)
Bogdanov A. A. (1990) War communism and state capitalism. Issues of Socialism, Moscow: Politizdat, pp. 311-320. (In Russian)
Bogdanov A. A. (2023) Tektology: The Universal Organizational Science, Moscow: URSS. (In Russian)
Brass Т. (1996) Popular culture, populist fiction(s): The agrarian utopiates of A. V. Chayanov, Ignatius Donnelly and Frank Capra. Journal of Peasant Studies, vol. 24, no 1-2, pp. 153-190.
Bruish К. (2014) Als Das Dorf noch Zukunf war Agrarismus und Expertise zwischen Zarenreich und Sowjetunion, Köln.
Chayanov A. V. (2019a) A Short Course on Cooperation.Russian Peasant Studies, vol. 4, no 2, pp. 8-56.
Chayanov A. V. (1920) State collectivism and peasant cooperation. Cooperative Life, no. 1-2, pp. 6-12. (In Russian)
Chayanov A. V. (2018a) Letter from A. V. Chayanov to V. M. Molotov on the current state of agriculture in the USSR compared with its pre-war state and the situation in agriculture of capitalist countries (October 6, 1927).Russian Peasant Studies, vol. 3, no 3, pp. 6-18.
Chayanov A. V. (2018b) What is the Agrarian Question? Russian Peasant Studies, vol. 3, no 2, pp. 6-33.
Chayanov A. V. (2019b) On differentiation of the peasant economy.Russian Peasant Studies, vol. 4, no 4, pp. 6-21.
Chayanov A. V. (2020a) Main Ideas and Methods of Social Agronomy (Part 1).Russian Peasant Studies, vol. 5, no 1, pp. 6-30.
Chayanov A. V. (2020b) Main Ideas and Methods of Social Agronomy (Part 2).Russian Peasant Studies, vol. 5, no 2, pp. 6-55.
Chayanov A. V. (2021) What will our national economy be like after the war? Russian Peasant Studies, vol. 6, no 1, pp. 6-12. (In Russian)
Chayanov A. V. (Kremnev Ivan) (1920) The Journey of My Brother Alexei to the Land of Peasant Utopia, Moscow. (In Russian)
Chayanov's School: Between Past and Future (2020) Collection of Materials of the International Scientific Conference of the Chayanov Research Center on October 22-23, 2020 / Ed. by A. M. Nikulin, M. G. Pugacheva, Moscow: Ekon-Inform. (In Russian)
Chibnik M. (1984) A cross-cultural examination of Chayanov's theory. Current Anthropology, vol. 25, no 3, pp. 335-340. (In Russian)
Durrenberger P. E. (1984) Chayanov, Peasants, and Economic Anthropology, Orlando: Harcourt Brace.
Ferns С. (1999) Narrating Utopia: Ideology, Gender, Form in Utopian Literature, Liverpool University Press.
Gare A. (2000) Aleksandr Bogdanov and systems theory. Democracy & Nature, vol. 6, no 3, pp. 341-359.
George L. (2021) Interpreting Alexander Chayanov's peasant utopia since 1991. History and Politics, vol. 38, pp. 9-34.
Gerasimov I. V. (1997) Human Soul in the Transitional Time: The Case of A. Chayanov, Kazan: ANNA. (In Russian)
Gloveli G. D. (2004) Red Star and Red Rose: From the history of Russian utopia. Bulletin of the International Institute of Alexander Bogdanov, no 3, pp. 71-95.
Grigoryan N. (2015) Revolution on Earth and on Mars: Malthusian thought experiments in the novels Red Star by A. Bogdanov and Aelita by A. N. Tolstoy. New Literary Observer, no 2, pp. 141-160. (In Russian)
Harrison M. (1975) Chayanov and the economics of the Russian peasantry. Journal of Peasant Studies, vol. 2, no 4, pp. 389-417.
Harrison M. (1979) Chayanov and the Marxists. Journal of Peasant Studies, vol. 7, no 1, pp. 86-100.
Klementsov N. (2011) A Martian Stranded on Earth: Alexander Bogdanov, Blood Transfusions, and Proletarian Science, Chicago-London: University of Chicago Press.
Merl S. (2022) Was Chayanov's concept of peasant agriculture under the Soviet rule realistic? The emerging of the kulturniki in answer to the Litsom k derevne policy.Russian Peasant Studies, vol. 7, no 2, pp. 6-37.
Nikulin A. (2011) Tragedy of a Soviet Faust: Chayanov and Central Asia 1917-1937. Soviet Era in Anthropology of Eurasia. Halle Studies, vol. 4, pp. 211-219.
Nikulin A., Trotsuk I. (2016) Utopian visions of contemporary rural-urban Russia. Third World Thematics: A TWQ Journal, vol. 1, no 5, pp. 673-690.
Nikulin A. M., Trotsuk I. V. (2023) Two and a half undeservedly forgotten conceptual foundations of rural sociology.RUDN Journal of Sociology, vol. 23, no 3, pp. 468-484. (In Russian)
Proceedings of the First All-Union Conference of Marxist Agrarians (1930), Moscow, vol. 1. (In Russian)
Raskov D. (2014) Socialist agrarian utopia in the 1920s: Chayanov. Oeconomia: History, Methodology, Philosophy, vol. 4, no 2, pp. 123-146. (In Russian)
Roberts R., Mutersbaugh T. (1996) On rereading Chayanov: Understanding agrarian transitions in the industrialized world. Environment and Planning A, vol. 28, pp. 951-956.
Schmitt G. (1992) The rediscovery of Alexander Chayanov. History of Political Economy, vol. 24, no 4, pp. 925-965.
Shanin T. (1986) Chayanov's message: Illuminations, miscomprehensions, and the contemporary ‘development theory'. Chayanov A. V. The Theory of Peasant Economy / Ed. by D. Thorner, B. Kerblay, R. E.F. Smith, Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
Shanin T., Nikulin A., Trotsuk I., van der Ploeg J. D. (2023) Peasants: Chayanov's Recovered Essays, Rugby: Practical Action Publishing.
Shanin T. (2009) Chayanov's treble death and tenuous resurrection: An essay about understanding, about roots of plausibility and about rural Russia. Journal of Peasant Studies, vol. 36, no 1, pp. 83-101.
Sharapov Yu.P. (1997) Lenin and Bogdanov: From cooperation to confrontation.Russian History, no 5, pp. 55-67. (In Russian)
Shcheglov A. (1937) Lenin's Fight against Bogdanov's Revision of Marxism, Moscow. (In Russian)
Trotsuk I. V. (2023) Rural human capital in the conceptual optics: Continuum and/or postism? RUDN Journal of Sociology, vol. 23, no 2, pp. 338-354. (In Russian)
Trotsuk I. V., Subbotina M. V. (2019) Happiness and heroism, personal and collective as main elements of the ‘bright future' in the Soviet (non)utopia.RUDN Journal of Sociology, vol. 19, no 4, pp. 835-848. (In Russian)
Uleri F. (2019) Capitalism and the peasant mode of production: A Chayanovian analysis. Russian Peasant Studies, vol. 6, no 3, pp. 43-60.
van der Ploeg J. D. (2013) Peasants and the Art of Farming: A Chayanovian Manifesto, Halifax: Fernwood Publishing.
Weber M. (1930) The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, Routledge.
White J. D. (2018) Red Hamlet. The Life and Ideas of Alexander Bogdanov, Leiden-Boston: Brill.
Yassour A. A. (2017) Bogdanov and His Work: A Guide to the Published and Unpublished Works of Alexander A. Bogdanov (Malinovsky) 1873-1928, London: Taylor & Francis.
